choose your location

East Aurora cafe
east aurora rooftop
Hamburg cafe + bar

Join us for live music with Bello Studios

March 27th from 5pm-7pm @ The Rooftop

book your reservation while spots are open!

Reserve a table at the rooftop

March 28th from 4pm-6pm @ Hamburg

RSVP with the link below

At Blue Eyed Baker, "homemade" isn't just a buzzword. It is the foundation of every single bite and sip you take. From our fresh artisan sourdough + hand cracked eggs to the hand crafted dressings + syrups, every aspect of your meal is crafted from scratch daily. We ditch the store-bought shortcuts, and ensure that every sandwich, drink, and pastry carries a depth of flavor that only comes from real ingredients and true culinary patience.

  • BEST MACARONS EVER!

    ★ ★ ★ ★ ★

    “Working with Blue Eyed Baker for our wedding was wonderful! They were easy to communicate with, had everything ready on time, and the macarons were amazing. I ordered 100 for about 120 people and they were all gone almost immediately once the dinner ended. I would highly recommend them for your wedding!”

    — MEGAN L.

  • AMAZING GLUTEN-FREE DESSERTS!

    ★ ★ ★ ★ ★

    “Blue Eyed Baker did such a wonderful job on our wedding desserts!! Everything looked and tasted great. Our guests thoroughly enjoyed them, and many were pleasantly surprised to learn that everything was gluten free! We are super happy with how they all turned out and appreciate that they did such a great job. Would highly recommend!”

    — KYLER K.

  • WORTH THE TRIP EVERY TIME.

    ★ ★ ★ ★ ★

    “Worth the trip every time. The macarons were so flavorful, and the cookies the perfect combination of crunchy and chewy. Overwhelmed by amazing options every trip.”

    — CHRIS W.

  • PERFECTION!

    ★ ★ ★ ★ ★

    “Blue Eyed Baker made the most delicious and beautiful desserts for our wedding! We had a main cake that was so delicious, then two other sheet cakes with different flavors, cupcakes, cookies, and macarons - everything received rave reviews from our guests! The team was so organized and helpful throughout the entire planning process. I would choose Blue Eyed Baker 1000x over!!”

    — HANNAH B.

SWEET REWARDS AWAIT YOU.

Indulge in the joy of baking and join a community that cherishes the simple, sweet moments in life. Sign up for our newsletter and rewards program today – your taste buds will thank you!

SIGN UP FOR REWARDS